This Resurrection Rolls post may contain affiliate links, which means I earn a small commission if you purchase something I recommend – at no additional cost to you! Thank you for supporting this blog!

You wrap a marshmallow in dough. You seal it shut. You bake it. When the rolls come out of the oven and you break one open, the marshmallow is gone. The center is completely hollow. The tomb is empty.

That’s the magic of resurrection rolls, and it never gets old. Our kids are always surprised when they crack open a roll and find nothing inside, even when they helped put the marshmallow in with their own hands ten minutes earlier. The science is simple – the marshmallow melts and absorbs into the dough during baking. But the experience feels like something more, and that’s what makes these rolls one of the best hands-on Easter traditions we have.

Each step in the recipe tells part of the Easter story. The white marshmallow represents Jesus – pure and sinless. The butter and cinnamon-sugar represent the oils and spices used to anoint His body for burial. The dough represents the linen cloth they wrapped Him in. Sealing the dough shut represents the sealed tomb. And the empty center when you break it open? That’s Easter morning. The tomb is empty. He is risen.

We either make these resurrection rolls or our Easter story cookies each year to teach the empty tomb lesson. To be honest, our kids prefer the rolls. They’re warm, gooey, coated in cinnamon and sugar, and taste like a cross between a cinnamon roll and a donut. You can make the dough from scratch or use frozen rolls – both work perfectly.

What You Need for Resurrection Rolls

For the dough (from scratch):

Dissolve 1 1/2 teaspoons of yeast in 2 tablespoons of warm water and let it bubble for 5 minutes. Add 3/4 cup warm water, 1 1/2 teaspoons olive oil, and 1 1/2 teaspoons salt. Stir in 2 to 3 cups of flour, half a cup at a time, until the dough stops being sticky. Knead for 2 to 3 minutes, place in a lightly oiled bowl, cover, and let it rise until doubled.

Shortcut option: Buy a package of frozen rolls or bread dough. Thaw completely and let it come to room temperature before using. If using frozen rolls, cut each roll in half before wrapping the marshmallow.

For the Rolls

Marshmallows: 15 large marshmallows. These represent Jesus – white, pure, and sinless. Each child gets one to hold, coat, and wrap. The marshmallow melts completely during baking, leaving the hollow center.

Butter: 6 tablespoons, melted. You’ll dip the marshmallow in butter and brush the sealed rolls before baking. The butter represents the oils used to anoint Jesus’s body for burial.

Cinnamon and sugar: Combine 2/3 cup sugar and 5 teaspoons cinnamon in a shallow bowl. Roll the buttered marshmallow in this mixture before wrapping. The cinnamon-sugar represents the spices used to prepare the body. It also makes the rolls taste incredible.

The Easter Story, Step by Step

Prepare everything before you start the story. Preheat the oven to 350°F. Roll out the dough and cut it into 3-inch squares. Place the melted butter in a bowl and the cinnamon-sugar in a separate shallow bowl. Have a lined baking sheet ready. This way you can move through the scripture readings without pausing to measure or prep.

Step 1: Give each child a marshmallow. The marshmallow represents Jesus Christ. He was pure, white, sinless, and perfect. Even though He was perfect, there were people who wanted Him dead. They crucified Him and He died on a cross. Read Mark 15:12–14.

Step 2: Roll the marshmallow in butter, then in cinnamon-sugar. Jesus’s friends and family loved Him deeply. In Jesus’s time, they prepared bodies for burial by anointing them with special oils and spices. The butter and cinnamon-sugar represent those oils and spices. Read John 19:39.

Wrapping and Sealing the Tomb

Step 3: Wrap the marshmallow in dough. Give each child a square of dough. Place the coated marshmallow in the center and fold the dough around it completely. The dough represents the fine linen cloth they wrapped Jesus’s body in. Read John 19:40.

Step 4: Seal the dough completely. Pinch every seam shut. Do not leave any openings – if the dough isn’t sealed, the marshmallow will leak out during baking and the “tomb” won’t be empty when you open it. Place sealed-side down on the baking sheet. Jesus was buried in a tomb, sealed with a heavy stone, and guarded by soldiers. Read Matthew 27:66.

Step 5: Brush with 3 strokes of butter and sprinkle with 3 pinches of cinnamon-sugar. Three strokes. Three pinches. Jesus’s body lay in the tomb for three days. Read Matthew 27:63.

The Empty Tomb

Step 6: Bake for 12 to 15 minutes at 350°F. While the rolls bake, the marshmallow melts completely and absorbs into the dough. The shell bakes into a golden, cinnamon-crusted roll with nothing inside.

Step 7: Let the rolls cool slightly, then break one open. After three days, Jesus’s friends went back to the tomb. They wanted to put more oils and spices on His body. When they arrived, they found the most incredible thing – the tomb was empty. Jesus had risen from the dead, just as He said He would. Read Matthew 28:5–8.

Let each child break open their own roll and discover the hollow center. The rolls are sweet – just like the resurrection story. Jesus died for us because He loves us. He is still with us, cheering us on and helping us every day. Because of Him, we can be saved.

Tips for Perfect Resurrection Rolls

Seal the dough completely. This is the most important step. If there are any gaps or openings in the dough, the melted marshmallow will leak out during baking. The roll will taste fine, but the “empty tomb” reveal will be ruined because sticky marshmallow will be oozing out the sides. Pinch every seam and place the rolls seam-side down on the baking sheet.

Use frozen rolls if you’re short on time. Homemade dough tastes better, but frozen rolls or bread dough work perfectly for the activity. Thaw them completely and let them come to room temperature. Cut each roll in half before wrapping so the dough is thin enough to seal properly around the marshmallow.

Prep everything before starting the story. Roll out the dough, cut it into squares, melt the butter, and mix the cinnamon-sugar before you gather the children. The experience works best as a flowing narrative, not a start-and-stop cooking class.

Don’t overbake. Twelve to fifteen minutes is enough. The rolls should be golden brown on the outside. Overbaking dries out the dough and the rolls lose their soft, gooey quality. You want them warm and tender when the children break them open.

Part of Our Holy Week Traditions

These resurrection rolls fit into our family’s Holy Week alongside our other faith-centered recipes. We start with fresh herb pasta on Palm Sunday, bake kiss cookies on Wednesday, share unleavened piadina with our Gethsemane olive oil dip on Thursday, and serve Italian Easter bread and baked lamb on Easter Sunday. The resurrection rolls (or our Easter story cookies) come on Saturday evening or Easter morning as the final “empty tomb” moment of the week.

Our Holy Week Activity Book walks families through each day of Holy Week with activities, recipes, coloring pages, and scriptural accounts from all four gospels. It gives you a complete framework for turning the week into a Christ-centered experience your children will carry with them for years.

This recipe pairs with our Holy Week Activity Book, which guides families through each day of Holy Week with recipes, activities, and scripture. For more family recipes, our Roots of Sicily cookbook has 167 authentic recipes and 139 family stories passed down through four generations.